**Are High-Fat Diets Doing More Harm Than Good?
The Hidden Impact on Metabolic Health, Inflammation & Biological Age**

Over the past decade, high-fat trends — keto, carnivore, low-carb/high-fat, “butter coffee” lifestyles — have surged in popularity. They promise weight loss, stable energy, sharper focus and metabolic freedom. But emerging research paints a different picture: for many people, especially women aged 30–50, sustained high-fat diets may actually accelerate inflammation, metabolic dysfunction and biological ageing. At Shimalia, we follow data — not trends. And the science shows that excessive dietary fat can work directly against longevity.
1. High-Fat Diets Can Impair Insulin Sensitivity — Quickly
Most people believe sugar causes insulin resistance. Research shows fat can cause it first.
High-fat meals (especially high in saturated fats) can:
-
Reduce insulin sensitivity
-
Increase liver fat
-
Block glucose uptake
-
Raise post-meal glucose spikes — even without carbs
What the science shows:
A controlled human study found that high-saturated-fat diets decreased insulin sensitivity and altered glucose metabolism in healthy individuals within days.
This means many people on high-fat diets appear to be in control of blood sugar — but internally, their metabolism is becoming less flexible and more stressed.
2. High-Fat Diets Increase Inflammation — One of the Core Drivers of Ageing
Chronic inflammation is one of the strongest predictors of biological age.
High-fat diets have been shown to:
-
Increase inflammatory cytokines
-
Impair blood vessel function
-
Elevate oxidative stress
-
Increase risk for metabolic syndrome
Inflammation is not just a biomarker — it affects sleep, mood, hormones, energy, recovery and immune resilience.
3. The Gut Microbiome Is Highly Sensitive to High-Fat Diets
Your microbiome regulates immunity, hormones, weight, cravings, mood and longevity.
High-fat diets have been shown to:
-
Reduce beneficial gut bacteria
-
Increase inflammatory microbes
-
Cause gut permeability (“leaky gut”)
-
Disrupt metabolic signalling
Over time, this contributes to bloating, fatigue, skin issues, hormonal disruption and slower metabolic rate.
4. Lipid Markers Often Rise on High-Fat Diets — Even When Weight Looks Normal
This is one of the most overlooked issues.
People on high-fat diets may still:
-
Raise ApoB
-
Increase LDL / non-HDL cholesterol
-
Worsen lipid particle quality
-
Increase Lp(a) risk expression
-
Show worsening vascular age
-
Experience increased hs-CRP inflammation
These markers are far more predictive of long-term health outcomes than weight or body fat percentage.
5. High-Fat Diets Can Be Particularly Hard on Women’s Hormones
Women have unique biological needs.
Excessive fat intake may:
-
Disrupt progesterone–oestrogen balance
-
Slow thyroid function
-
Impair hormonal detoxification in the liver
-
Affect cortisol rhythms
-
Increase PMS or perimenopause symptoms
Many women report feeling flat, anxious, puffy, hormonally chaotic or exhausted on long-term high-fat diets — even when they initially felt great during the first few weeks.
6. Longevity Research Does Not Support Long-Term High-Fat Eating
Across major longevity research areas — Blue Zones, large cohort studies, centenarian regions, cardiovascular and metabolic literature — the diets associated with longer life consistently include:
-
Lower saturated fat
-
Higher fibre
-
High fruit and vegetable intake
-
Lean or plant-based proteins
-
Low inflammatory load
-
Stable metabolic markers
No long-lived population has ever consumed a long-term high-fat diet.
The Shimalia Approach: Precision Nutrition for Biological Age Reversal
Your nutritional plan should be shaped by your biomarkers, not by trends.
We use:
✓ Blood biomarkers
✓ GlycanAge biological age testing
✓ Withings Body Scan metrics
✓ Hormone analysis
✓ Inflammation and metabolic markers
✓ Personal dietary response
…to create an elegant, balanced, anti-inflammatory nutritional framework that supports longevity, energy, hormonal balance and cellular repair.
Not extremes.
Not deprivation.
Not fad diets.
Just precision.
Studies & Scientific Evidence Cited
Here are the peer-reviewed sources that support the statements above:
Metabolic & Insulin Sensitivity
Metabolic & Insulin Sensitivity
von Frankenberg et al. Metabolism. 2017.
High-saturated-fat diets decrease insulin sensitivity, even in healthy individuals.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26615402/
Hernández et al. Journal of Clinical Investigation. 2017.
A single high-fat meal alters liver fat metabolism and reduces insulin sensitivity.
https://www.jci.org/articles/view/89444
Inflammation
Duan et al. Frontiers in Immunology. 2018.
High-fat diets trigger systemic inflammation and immune dysregulation.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fimmu.2018.02649/full
Gut Microbiome
Mamun et al. Cells. 2025.
High-fat diets reduce microbial diversity and increase inflammatory species.
https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4409/14/6/463
Basak et al. Nutrition Reviews / ScienceDirect. 2022.
Shows how dietary fats reshape the microbiome and trigger metabolic inflammation.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S175646462200096
Cardiovascular Markers
Wali et al. Nutrients. 2020.
Mechanisms by which saturated fats increase lipid toxicity, ceramides and cardiovascular risk.
https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/12/5/1505
Additional Landmark Studies (Historical Foundation)
Randle Cycle Research (Randle et al., 1963) — established that high fatty acid availability inhibits glucose uptake, foundational to understanding insulin resistance.
Boden et al., 1994, 2001
High-fat infusions in humans rapidly cause insulin resistance by increasing free fatty acids.
Mensink & Katan, 1992
Saturated fats increase LDL cholesterol significantly more than other macronutrients.
Vessby et al., 2001
Replacing saturated fat with unsaturated fat improves insulin sensitivity.